Best movies like Fire Island
Last updated March 2024
Looking for movies like Fire Island? Share your expertise to direct others find tv series and movies you've already watched that might suit them too. Boost the circle of people putting forward videos to one another. We appreciate your contribution!
Plot Summary:
The perfect summer vacation quickly spirals out of control for a group of friends on the infamous, picturesque party getaway of Fire Island as they find themselves caught in a web of sex, lies and cold blooded murder.
IMDB Rating: 2.7
IMDB Votes: 361
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 83 min
Plot tags: queer horror, slasher, slasher horror
Best tv shows and movies like Fire Island (2023):
Similar in 88%
Killer Unicorn (2018)
Plot Summary:
Danny is your average Brooklyn party boy. This year, he and his friends couldn't be more excited about the upcoming "Brooklyn Annual Enema Party"; one of Brooklyn's biggest party. While the night starts out fun, it quickly takes a turn for the worst when Danny is attacked by a stranger. In the end, his fabulous drag queen and queer friends are able to save his life, but not without deadly consequences. A year later, Danny is still going throughout the aftermath of that horrible incident and refuses to go to this year's upcoming "Brooklyn Annual Enema Party". His friends want Danny to face his fears and go back out into the world. Danny refuses, but when a new boy, PuppyPup, enters his life, Danny decides to give his social life and the Brooklyn nightlife scene a second chance. It isn't until his friends start to disappear and get killed in gruesome ways that Danny realizes that his life, and everyone else who helped him that night, are in danger.
IMDB Rating: 3.1
IMDB Votes: 224
Genere: Horror
Country: USA
Duration: 74 min
Plot tags: slasher, retro, queer horror, queer cinema
Similar in 77%
B&B (2017)
Plot Summary:
Gay Londoners Marc and Fred plan for a weekend of mischief, baiting the Christian owner of a remote Christian B&B. Events take a deadly turn when another guest arrives, who they think might have something more sinister in mind.
IMDB Rating: 5.5
IMDB Votes: 836
Genere: Thriller
Country: UK
Duration: 87 min
Plot tags: suspense, tense, touching, unusual plot structure, queer horror, sexy, exciting, queer cinema
Similar in 75%
Creatures from the Pink Lagoon (2006)
Plot Summary:
In 1967, a chemical plant near a discreet roadside restroom causes an outbreak of gay zombies. At a near by beach cottage a group of best friends must fight off the undead.
IMDB Rating: 5.2
IMDB Votes: 225
Genere: Comedy, Horror
Country: USA
Duration: 71 min
Plot tags: queer horror, campy
Similar in 83%
Fear the Night (2023)
Plot Summary:
During a bachelorette party in a secluded California farmhouse, masked intruders launch a brutal attack, forcing eight women to fight for survival. Led by Tess, a troubled military veteran, they unite to defend themselves throughout a harrowing night.
IMDB Rating: 4.8
IMDB Votes: 3000
Genere: Action, Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 92 min
Plot tags: slasher
Similar in 90%
The Brotherhood VI: Initiation (2009)
Plot Summary:
When a group of sexy, young pledges arrive at a secluded cabin for their initiation into the Gamma Kappa fraternity, they're met by a blood-thirsty lumberjack, who won't stop until every one of them is dead.
IMDB Rating: 3.2
IMDB Votes: 173
Genere: Horror
Country: USA
Duration: 86 min
Plot tags: suspense, slasher
Similar in 78%
Bear Creek (2017)
Plot Summary:
A pack of friends in Denver's gay bear community go for the camping trip of a life time filled with fun, laughs and a hot encounter. It all seems innocent enough until a rampaging sociopath joins them ensuring a trip they'll never forget.
IMDB Rating: 4.6
IMDB Votes: 59
Genere: Horror
Country: USA
Duration: 90 min
Plot tags: independent film
Similar in 85%
The Brotherhood IV: The Complex (2005)
Plot Summary:
Lee Hanlon, the smartest student at an elite military school called the Complex, is intrigued by the academy's Black Skulls brotherhood but finds himself thrust into the role of global savior when he discovers their devilish origin.
IMDB Rating: 3.5
IMDB Votes: 316
Genere: Horror
Country: USA, Canada
Duration: 96 min
Plot tags: suspense, erotic
Similar in 88%
Terror at Tenkiller (1986)
Plot Summary:
Unsuspecting college students are stalked by a killer at a lake during summer vacation.
IMDB Rating: 2.9
IMDB Votes: 813
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 87 min
Plot tags: slasher, relaxing, slasher horror, independent film
Similar in 84%
Consequences (2006)
Plot Summary:
Consequences introduces us to Max, Jimmy, Norm, Nick and Jason at the age of eighteen. Friends since early childhood, they have bonded deeper than natural brothers. We, once again, meet them at age forty and learn how their lives have unfolded as we experience their marriages, strengths and disappointments. Together they are capable of celebrating with each other their emotions in an open and honest fashion. The group is together now on their annual football weekend, this year in Philadelphia. While bonding and enjoying the vibrant nightlife, they become separated only to find a darkness they have never known. It becomes a struggle of life or death. The friends find themselves disconnected from each other but ultimately gain a stronger respect for one another than they ever thought possible. Realizing that everyone must pay the price, they all have to deal with Consequences.
IMDB Rating: 2.9
IMDB Votes: 137
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 86 min
Plot tags:
Similar in 79%
The Ghost Dance (1982)
Plot Summary:
The spirit of a long-dead warrior possesses the body of an Indian medicine man and turns him into a homicidal maniac.
IMDB Rating: 4.3
IMDB Votes: 263
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 96 min
Plot tags: slasher, psychotronic, independent film, slasher horror, cult film
Similar in 76%
In the Blood (2006)
Plot Summary:
Cassidy is a senior at a NYC college and he's trying to balance the demands of school, his role as big brother to Jessica, a freshman at the same school and his role as best buddy to horn-dog Mike with his emerging feelings of attraction to men. This is further complicated by a string of co-ed murders on campus for which his sister fits the victim profile.
IMDB Rating: 4.8
IMDB Votes: 320
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 82 min
Plot tags: rough, serious, slasher, suspenseful, scary, tense, mind bending, realistic, surprise ending
Similar in 82%
Death of the Jackal (1984)
Plot Summary:
A psycho-killer is on the loose targeting only young women. Grisly deaths pile up, one after another. The real problem is not finding out who he is, but instead, how to stop him.
IMDB Rating: 6.4
IMDB Votes: 63
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: Mexico
Duration: 90 min
Plot tags: slasher, detective, splatter, slasher horror
Similar in 90%
Blood Is Blood (2016)
Plot Summary:
For siblings Brie, Daniel, Crew, and Jess, family has always come first. But when Crew (Daniel DiTomasso) invites his girlfriend Sara (Kate French) into the family, distrust begins to bubble between the siblings. Seeing Sara as a threat, Brie (Fiona Dourif) grows spiteful and increasingly suspicious that she is being replaced. That is, until the night Crew attempts to murder her in their family house. Traumatized, Brie is sent to a mental facility where she is tormented by hallucinations of Crew from the night of the attack. But when the visions begin to bleed into reality, Brie starts to fear that it’s not just her sanity that’s in danger, and she flees the facility. In a frantic attempt to return to her remaining siblings and warn them, Brie begins to uncover a trail of gory, sinister secrets that lead her to believe that she might not know her family as well as she thought.
IMDB Rating: 4.1
IMDB Votes: 290
Genere: Horror, Mystery, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 80 min
Plot tags: slasher, bloody, hood
Similar in 85%
The Erotic Circus (1969)
Plot Summary:
Decadent swinging speed dealer Louie and his two lady friends Mary and Debbie decide to pay a visit to Louie's sister, who lives in a remote woodland area with her meek son Jamie and weird caretaker Yenos. However, things soon turn nasty when a killer decides to start bumping off the unwanted guests.
IMDB Rating: 4.1
IMDB Votes: 60
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 69 min
Plot tags: erotic, slasher, slasher horror
Similar in 82%
The Brotherhood V: Alumni (2009)
Plot Summary:
A year after a mean-spirited prom prank turned deadly, the most popular students of Sunnydale High are summoned back for a surprise reunion, only to find themselves at the mercy of a relentless killer.
IMDB Rating: 2.8
IMDB Votes: 323
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 86 min
Plot tags: suspense, surprise ending
Similar in 75%
Naked Fear (1999)
Plot Summary:
Camden, who suffers from agoraphobia, the fear of open spaces, takes in roommate Randy Tommy Sweeney, who suffers from claustrophobia, the fear of closed spaces. Unfortunately, Randy turns out to be a serial killer, and Camden becomes a prisoner in his own apartment.
IMDB Rating: 5.3
IMDB Votes: 122
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 79 min
Plot tags: bloody, slasher, independent film, slasher horror
Similar in 79%
They/Them (2022)
Plot Summary:
Campers at an LGBTQ+ conversion camp endure unsettling psychological techniques while the campsite is stalked by a mysterious killer.
IMDB Rating: 3.9
IMDB Votes: 11000
Genere: Horror, Mystery, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 104 min
Plot tags: slasher, suspense, queer horror, intellectual, spooky, psychological thriller, psychological horror, slasher horror, psychological, queer cinema
Similar in 80%
The Blackening (2022)
Plot Summary:
A group of Black friends reunite for a Juneteenth weekend getaway only to find themselves trapped in a remote cabin with a twisted killer.
IMDB Rating: 6.0
IMDB Votes: 16000
Genere: Comedy, Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 97 min
Plot tags: slasher, slasher horror, horror comedy, parody
Similar in 79%
Scab (2005)
Plot Summary:
When a one-night stand turns Ajay into a vampire, he decides misery really does love company and tries to suck his friends Teague and Floor into a life of bloodlust.
IMDB Rating: 4.1
IMDB Votes: 126
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 101 min
Plot tags: psychotronic
Similar in 83%
Exploited (2022)
Plot Summary:
A college freshman becomes obsessed with the previous owner of his school issued laptop, a webcam model whose last session may have ended in murder.
IMDB Rating: 4.3
IMDB Votes: 967
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 81 min
Plot tags: erotic
Similar in 86%
Hellbent (2004)
Plot Summary:
Halloween in West Hollywood, two guys making out in a park are interrupted by a serial killer. Later that night, a group of gay kids decide to visit to the site of the murders.
IMDB Rating: 5.5
IMDB Votes: 3000
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 84 min
Plot tags: slasher, suspense, rough, serious, suspenseful, queer horror, bloody, dark, controversial, homoerotic
Similar in 76%
Pitchfork (2016)
Plot Summary:
A group of friends return home with a friend to help him share a secret only to learn that sometimes older secrets are even more deadly.
IMDB Rating: 3.0
IMDB Votes: 4000
Genere: Horror
Country: USA
Duration: 94 min
Plot tags: slasher, suspense, psychotronic, scary, bleak, disturbing, psychological, dark drama, queer horror
Similar in 82%
The Pit and the Pendulum (2009)
Plot Summary:
Seven students answer an advertisement to participate in an experiment to explore how the sensation of pain can be eliminated. Arriving at a secluded institute, they are welcomed by mysterious scientist JB Divay. Initially, JB's fascination with hypnosis, clocks and cactus plants are dismissed by the group as mere eccentricities. But as the students begin to disappear one by one, they begin to question JB's true intentions.
IMDB Rating: 2.7
IMDB Votes: 475
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 87 min
Plot tags: psychological, serious, scary, surprise ending, tense, suspense, captivating, melancholic, erotic, queer horror
Similar in 86%
The Brotherhood III: Young Demons (2002)
Plot Summary:
A group of devil-may-care teenagers discover they've mistakenly called upon the Prince of Darkness in this flashy horror story.
IMDB Rating: 2.3
IMDB Votes: 541
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA, Canada
Duration: 82 min
Plot tags: scary, serious, suspenseful, homoerotic, erotic, suspense, slasher, independent film, gay cinema, campy
Similar in 86%
Honeymoon Horror (1982)
Plot Summary:
Imagine every newlywed's fantasy, a rustic secluded lover's paradise- Honeymoon Island. What starts as a weekend of love, turns into a nightmare of blood and terror for three young innocent couples. What lurks in the shadows of Honeymoon Lodge? Is it the caretaker, or perhaps something more fiendish and deadly? Honeymoon Island, where newlyweds joined in holy matrimony spend their wedding night screaming in terror!.
IMDB Rating: 3.8
IMDB Votes: 377
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 88 min
Plot tags: slasher, bloody, grindhouse
Similar in 87%
The Retreat (2021)
Plot Summary:
Renee and Valerie, a couple at a cross roads in their relationship, leave the city to spend the week at a remote cabin with friends. But when they arrive, their friends are nowhere to be found. As they stumble through their relationship woes, they discover they are being hunted by a group of militant extremists who are determined to exterminate them.
IMDB Rating: 4.9
IMDB Votes: 2000
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: Canada
Duration: 82 min
Plot tags: slasher, scary, bleak, suspense, suspenseful, disturbing, psychotronic, queer horror, slasher horror, queer cinema
Similar in 76%
Dead Tone (2007)
Plot Summary:
As another semester draws to a close at the University of Dreyskill, a simple game dreamt to help students avoid studying becomes a bloody battle for survival in this stalk-and-slash frightener from filmmaking duo Brian Hooks and Deon Taylor.
IMDB Rating: 4.6
IMDB Votes: 3000
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 100 min
Plot tags: slasher, scary, serious, suspenseful, teen horror, realistic, psychological, suspense, light, detective
Similar in 78%
Shallow Ground (2004)
Plot Summary:
A naked teenage boy covered in blood appears at a remote sheriff's station one year after the brutal unsolved murder of a local girl. Now Sheriff Jack Shepherd, guilt ridden over the girl's murder, must confront his own demons as he desperately searches for the boy's true identity and possible victims. Little does Jack realize that he has started down a path that will bring him face to face with an unthinkable horror. Before sunrise the living will pay for the pain the dead have suffered.
IMDB Rating: 4.9
IMDB Votes: 5000
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 97 min
Plot tags: psychological, rough, serious, suspenseful, suspense, slasher, disturbing, scary, spooky, surprise ending
Similar in 75%
Sick (2022)
Plot Summary:
In the midst of the pandemic, college student Parker and her best friend Miri decide to self-quarantine at her family's lake house, where they will be alone — or so they think.
IMDB Rating: 6.0
IMDB Votes: 18000
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 83 min
Plot tags: slasher, scary, atmospheric, slasher horror, interesting
Similar in 89%
Nobody Gets Out Alive (2012)
Plot Summary:
A group of college students escape their troubled lives but only to find themselves fighting for their lives from a revenge seeking mad man.
IMDB Rating: 3.1
IMDB Votes: 877
Genere: Horror, Thriller
Country: USA
Duration: 77 min
Plot tags: slasher, suspenseful, rough, serious, suspense, tense, captivating, psychological, retro, scary